Skip to main content

New Tree Planters Along St Nicholas and Irwin Street

From "2023 PB Cluster 1"

Go to the project

This idea proposes upgrading existing shallow planters (along the south side of St Nicholas Street, from Inkerman to Irwin Street) with a raised bed for gardening. 

Parks, Forestry, and Recreation staff have reviewed this proposal and estimates that a cement dugout around a tree would cost approximately $10,000 per tree.

Internal ID: TS-11

*Note: Ideas that proceed to the voting stage are edited by my office to ensure they are clear, concise, and is complete with images. For accountability and transparency purposes, the original description, as input by the resident, can be found below.

Original Description:

So for many years the residents at The Mews (the condo Townhomes that stretch along south along St Nicholas Street from Inkerman to Irwin Street and west along Irwin Street) have planted flowers in the tree beds in front their units.  Many people comment on how pretty the street looks with flowers planted and the trees. But the existing beds are shallow and are not well protected from people and dogs and other animals. Attempts to put up flimsy plastic fencing as not worked well. 

Avid gardeners in The Mews would take responsibility for planting and maintaining the flowers. We are simply asking for a better tree well and barrier to support the addition of flowers, as well as to support the growth of the trees. There are 17 trees – 8 on St Nicholas and 9 on Irwin.  We are only proposing the trees directly in front The Mews at this point, until we can see if further community support exists for extending the flower beds to trees that run in front of the Polo Club along Irwin and the opposite sides of Irwin and St Nicholas Streets.

Note: This is one idea which can be scoped in a range of cost brackets, with associated investments ranging from large to very significant. It is hoped that there will be ongoing dialogue with the Councillor’s office to qualify and shape this idea further as design and cost input is received from staff experts at the City, and prior to it being submitted for voting.

Comments(7)

Most recent comments have loaded.
I am one of the avid gardeners on Irwin Street. Streetscape is very important to me and it gives me great pleasure to know that we are contributing to beautifying the neighbourhood. Installing some form of a permanent barrier or fencing under each tree would certainly enhance the life of the flowers and the trees. Something similar to what has been installed on the east side of Bay Street north of Grosvenor might be the answer.
  • 1 like
Its 10,000 dollars per tree but the budget allocation calculator is only dedcuting 10,000, is its 20 trees - the total cost should be $200,000
  • 1 like
Profile of Ann Hatch
Posted by:Ann Hatch
3 years ago
Please make sure the east side of St. Nicholas is included (we are very jealous of the nice work our neighbours on the west side of the street have done!)
  • 3 likes
I am one of the owners and I maintain a small garden around the city owned tree. Frequently, passersby comment on how this contributes to a nice streetscape for all to enjoy. Erecting permanent fencing would both make it easier for the current gardeners to maintain and encourage others to participate.
  • 3 likes
This is maintained currently by a few owners. Most owners assumed maintained by City. If the city can contribute it will us maintain the street appeal for the area
  • 3 likes
Profile of Lee Day
Posted by:Lee Day
3 years ago
The current fencing doesn’t last more than 2 years and the replacement cost is absorbed by a minority of homeowners. Renters don’t contribute and new owners think the Board provides the fencing along with the plantings. The City has never contributed a cent. The cost of soil and plants (per plot) is usually $125.00 plus! Daily maintenance is done by owners!
  • 3 likes
Would be a nice addition to one of the nicest streets in the neighbourhood
  • 3 likes

Share

Posted by

Current status

Approved/In Progress

Tags

Nature and biodiversity